Clueless about PoE? Even though they tell you it's shorthand for power over ethernet. I get it. You probably want a panoramic view, a deep understanding of it.
Power over Ethernet (PoE) means electrical power over your ethernet cable, meaning plug in a PoE cable and no other power cable is needed.
What was PoE technology first invented for? What problem was it trying to fix? We all know that whenever something is invented, it must come to solve some problem.
Let’s travel back to the year 2000. A smart guy in Cisco found something that pained him when he looked at the VoIP phone. That is why this thing has to be connected with two cables: a power cable and an ethernet cable. Why can’t we put them together in one cable?
He must have read the story that in the old days, pencils and erasers were sold separately. An intelligent guy came up with the idea of why don’t we put them together because they are supposed to be used together. Boom! Eraser on Pencil, AKA eraser-tipped pencil, pencil-plus-eraser, or whatever you call it. Great invention and great sales.
OK. Putting an eraser on a pencil is easy. But how can we make one cable transmit power and data at the same time? Trust me. It’s easier than you think.
First, I’m assuming that you are not an electrician and do not have any electrical background. So I will give you the plainest explanation.
The Ethernet cable has eight wires that makeup four pairs. It turns out that only two pairs are used for data transmission while the other two pairs are left idle. It's that simple. Just use the idle ones to transmit power. This is one way, and it’s called Mode B or Alternative B. When there is a Mode B, there must be a Mode A.
Mode A is also very simple. Use the data transmitting pairs to transmit power. Wait, you can do that? How?
Phantom power feed technique. That’s all I can tell you. Otherwise, you will have to have an electrical background to understand.
Perhaps the following two pictures will give you a clearer look.
Fig.1 Mode A diagram(credit to Youtube channel: ALL ABOUT ELECTRONICS)
Fig.2 Mode B diagram(credit to Youtube channel: ALL ABOUT ELECTRONICS)
Mode A and Mode B talk about how we transfer power over Ethernet cables, but other than that, there is a fundamental question PoE has to consider. That is, PoE has power, but some devices can’t handle that much power without an adapter.
For example, a PoE power sourcing equipment (PSE) provides 15.4W, but the powered device (PD) only requires 6W. Then the PD may fry. That’s very simple. Imagine your family is moving, and your dad asks you to help carry a heavy box. Just because your dad can carry it doesn’t mean you can. If your dad just throws that box at you, you might get hurt.
Therefore, when the IEEE first ratified the 802.3af standard in 2003, they made the rule that all the PSE (power sourcing equipment) must send a detecting signal to see if the receiving device is a PoE device and how much power it can withstand. They call it Handshake.
What does standard mean? Standard means someone is above, and someone is below. Before the standard came out, some manufacturers had already produced PoE products without the Handshake function.
They call it passive PoE. Pretty easy to understand because it doesn’t actively give the handshake. Passive PoE doesn't adhere to any standards and is completely usable as long as you know not to plug the wrong things into it.
As I said, initially, the PoE was just to power those low-power budgets devices like VoIP and wireless access points(WAPs). Therefore, the IEEE 802.3af standard was tailored for them, specifying that PSEs only provide a maximum of 15.4W of power.
And due to the cable resistance and power loss, the PDs would only receive 12.95W, which is still adequate for VoIPs, WAPs, and most cameras.
However, the times are progressing, technology is developing, and the standards are slowly failing to keep up with the needs. We need more power!
For example, the pan tilt zoom(PTZ) cameras wouldn’t operate ideally under a 12.95W power supply. So, we should give it more.
In 2009, IEEE ratified 802.3at standard(AKA PoE+). It doubled the power supply to 30W.
Still not enough? All right. Let’s double it again. In 2018, the newest version was released, 802.3bt(AKA PoE++), which contains two types. Type 3 and type 4. Wait, you just jumped to 3 and 4? What about 1 and 2?
802.3af(PoE) is referred to type 1 and 802.3at(PoE+) is referred to type 2.
What’s the difference between type 3 and type 4? After all, they are under the very one standard. The answer is type 3 offers a 60W supply, and type 4 offers a 100W. So the difference is double and triple. Joke aside. You might wonder why they are under the same standard. Why don’t we use PoE+++ to refer to type 4?
Because both type 3 and type 4 utilize the entire four pairs to transmit data! Which enables them to reach the gigabit speeds of 1000M, compared to 10/100M for type 1 and type 2. By the way, they also use the whole four pairs to transmit power. That’s the reason they can offer 60W and 90W as well.
With the new 802.3bt standard, you can even use PoE to power a laptop while giving it a stable internet connection. “One cable; deals all.” That’s probably a catchy commercial. But in real life, you also need a PoE docking station to power your USB-C-capable laptop like Macbook.
The figure below illustrates the difference in each parameter of the 4 types.
Fig.4 Standard of PoE(credit to Youtube channel: ALL ABOUT ELECTRONICS)
What is it for? This is a question that strikes straight to the soul. You probably think: Haven’t you already answered that?
Actually, practically speaking, most of the applications of PoE are to connect IP cameras. So I have to tell you about IP cameras.
Why do you need an IP camera? I will talk about this in detail in another in-depth article. Here I give you a simple answer: It’s just way better than an analog camera, just like you would choose an Apple smartphone rather than an old Nokia flip phone.
The new phone comes with a new power adapter. New IP cameras require PoE.
Another thing PoE can do is remove your bulky power brick, which is quite obvious because even the power cable is gone. So there is no need for a professional electrician, saving you a lot of money.
The most vital one is that it cannot exceed 100 meters(328ft). 100 meters. Such a perfect number. It looks very unnatural. Someone must have manually specified it.
Yes. You are right. IEEE set the rules. And it’s actually THE thing that would trouble you. Sometimes, you just want a longer connection.
But sorry. 100 meters(328ft). You can’t break the constitution. However, we can still add amendments.
For example, you can put on an extender, or two(at most), to extend the length 100 meters(328ft) per extender.
Fig.5 PoE extender
That’s the end.
I hope you now have a clear understanding of PoE. If you don’t, don’t worry, I’m writing more PoE-related articles. After all, this is just an overview article on PoE.
Click the links below to find answers to more PoE questions.